Order your ARC 2014-2015 Salon Catalogue

Click here to become a sponsor

Nymphs and Satyr, by William Bouguereau (Detail)
click to learn more click to learn more click to learn more
click to learn more click to learn more click to learn more
click to see upcoming exhibition information Click to visit the Living Masters Gallery Click to see the winners of the 2016 ARC Salon click to see the winners of the 2016 ARC Scholarship

  • [1 post]
  • Academia and Modernism [26 posts]
  • Advice to Artists [16 posts]
  • Aesthetics [55 posts]
  • ARC Living Master, Artist, and Sponsor Testimonials [11 posts]
  • ARC Scholarship Thank You Letters [4 posts]
  • Architecture [1 post]
  • Art and Politics [13 posts]
  • Art as a Profession [1 post]
  • Art Criticism [9 posts]
  • Art History Anecdotes [5 posts]
  • Art History Timeline [3 posts]
  • Art Practice [9 posts]
  • Art's Place in Society [27 posts]
  • Artspeak 101 [6 posts]
  • Ateliers [10 posts]
  • Book Reviews [1 post]
  • Canvas Priming or Preparation [1 post]
  • College Activism: Return to Realism [52 posts]
  • College Curricula [9 posts]
  • Commentary on Specific Artists [33 posts]
  • Definitions of Art [8 posts]
  • Digital Art [20 posts]
  • Discussion: William Bouguereau [3 posts]
  • Exhibitions [5 posts]
  • Fine Art and Photography [5 posts]
  • Freedom of Expression [6 posts]
  • Frequently Asked Questions [30 posts]
  • Funding for the Arts [1 post]
  • Good Art Versus Traditionalism [1 post]
  • Hockney Completely Refuted [53 posts]
  • Illustration as a Fine Art [27 posts]
  • Impressionism vs Academism [5 posts]
  • Juries and Competitions [1 post]
  • Letters to ARC [472 posts]
  • Life of an Artist [7 posts]
  • Modernist Heroes Reconsidered [62 posts]
  • Modernist Orthodoxy on Campus [4 posts]
  • Moral Relativism [1 post]
  • Music and Art [2 posts]
  • Myth & Religion in Art [7 posts]
  • Nudity [1 post]
  • Paint Pigments [8 posts]
  • Perspective [2 posts]
  • Picasso: Discussion by experts [14 posts]
  • Places to See [1 post]
  • Post of the Week [2 posts]
  • Realism on the Rise [2 posts]
  • Regarding GoodArt and ARC [10 posts]
  • Renaissance Art [1 post]
  • Responses to ARC [4 posts]
  • Scholarship [1 post]
  • Sculpture [1 post]
  • Setting up the Studio [6 posts]
  • Students at non-ARC Approved schools [1 post]
  • Technical questions discussed and answered [6 posts]
  • Techniques: Art Manuals [1 post]
  • Techniques: Draughtsmanship [33 posts]
  • Techniques: Oil Painting [80 posts]
  • Techniques: Sculpture [2 posts]
  • The Case of Pete Panse [4 posts]
  • The Marketplace [19 posts]
  • The Origins of Modernism [6 posts]
  • What is Art? [24 posts]

  • Feelings in Art

    by Fred Ross

    My one disagreement with you Tim is where you say, "I think many overly poetic works have the power of a fishbowl."

    Unless you think a fishbowl is an example of great poetry, that's a contradiction in terms. If a work is no more "poetic than a fish bowl" then it's not in fact "poetic" at all, which is the same as saying that the work in question was not "poetic". Therefore it's not possible for a work to be "overly poetic" since you've actually defined "overly poetic" as the same as "un-poetic".

    That's no different than saying that something which is "overly strong" is actually weak, or something which is "overly hard" is "soft", etc. etc.

    I think what you mean here is that when an artist self-consciously sets out to be poetic, they often don't succeed at all, whereas when an artist sets out to express some powerful aspect of the human condition, and does so successfully, that their work may achieve being beautiful and "poetic".

    I also love works that permit interpretation and can tear you in different directions, but always within the emotional playing field that was intended by the artist.

    Dicksee's Yseult tugs your feelings between sympathy for the beautiful queen who has sent her agents to thwart the unfaithful plans of her husband, the dying King Tristan, from seeing one last time his unrequited lover. Is she the victim or victimizer? But I don't think any one will look at that work and think of being bored, baking cookies or the 67 Mets. While the meaning may be unclear, it's really quite clear what is unclear. Even if you don't know the story, there is a limited range in which one's interpretations can reasonably vary.